Bottom Watering vs Top Watering: Which Is Better?

Bottom watering looks tidy on social media: set the pot in a tray, walk away, come back to damp soil all through the pot. The catch is what it leaves behind, because water drawn up from below carries fertilizer salts to the surface and never washes them out. This guide compares bottom watering vs top watering and shows when each one is the right call.

Quick summary: Top watering is the better default for most houseplants because water running down through the pot flushes out salts. Bottom watering works for plants that dislike wet leaves, such as African violets, and for soil that has dried so hard it repels water. If you bottom water, top water every few weeks to rinse the mix.

  • Colorado State University Extension says top watering is better than bottom watering because bottom watering lets soluble salts build up
  • The University of Maryland Extension recommends flushing pots with at least twice the pot volume of water every 4 to 6 months
  • Never leave a pot standing in water after either method

Bottom Watering vs Top Watering: Which Is Better?

Top watering is better for routine care, and bottom watering is a tool for specific cases. Colorado State University Extension states that it is better to water plants from the top than to subirrigate. Watering from the bottom can lead to an accumulation of soluble salts in and on the surface of the soil.

Salts come from fertilizer and from minerals in tap water. When water moves down and out of the drainage holes, it carries some of those salts with it. When water only moves up from a saucer, the salts travel to the top of the soil and stay there. They show up as a white crust and brown leaf tips.

Use this comparison to decide which method fits a given plant and situation.

FactorTop wateringBottom watering
Salt buildupFlushes salts out the drainage holesPulls salts up to the surface
Wet leaves and crownCan splash leaves and crownKeeps leaves and crown dry
Dried-out, shrunken soilWater runs down the gap at the pot edgeRewets the whole root ball
Time per plantAbout a minute10 to 30 minutes of soaking
Risk of overwateringLow if you empty the saucerHigher if the pot sits too long
Pest spreadLowShared trays can move pests between pots
Top watering suits routine care; bottom watering suits specific problems.

How to Top Water a Houseplant

Pour water in a slow stream over the whole soil surface until it runs out of the drainage holes. The University of Maryland Extension advises irrigating so that water drains from the bottom of the container, then dumping any excess from the saucer.

Water draining from the hole of a plant pot into a saucer
  1. Check the soil first with the finger test.
  2. Pour at the soil in a slow stream, not the leaves, moving around the pot so the whole surface gets wet.
  3. Stop when water runs from the drainage holes.
  4. Wait 10 to 15 minutes, then empty the saucer.

Room-temperature water is the safer choice. The University of Illinois Extension says to use only room-temperature water and not cold water.

How to Bottom Water Plants (and When to Do It)

Set the pot in a few inches of water and let the mix soak it up through the drainage holes. The University of Illinois Extension describes sub-irrigation this way: place the pot in a few inches of water. Remove it once moisture has wicked up and shows at the top of the soil.

Small houseplant pots standing in a shallow sink of water
  1. Fill a sink, tub or tray with 1 to 3 inches of room-temperature water.
  2. Set the pot in the water; the pot needs drainage holes.
  3. Leave it until the soil surface looks or feels damp, which takes 10 to 30 minutes in most pots.
  4. Lift the pot out and let the excess drain away before you put it back.

Bottom watering earns its place in three situations:

  • Plants that hate wet leaves. Cold water on African violet leaves causes pale ring spots. The Pacific Northwest Plant Disease Management Handbook traces ring spot to a sudden drop in leaf temperature and recommends watering from below.
  • Hydrophobic soil. Peat-based mix that dries out all the way shrinks from the pot wall and sheds water poured on top. A 20 to 30 minute soak rewets it.
  • Seedlings and fine seed. Water from above can wash small seeds out of place.
Bottom watering vs top watering: where salts goTwo pots side by side. Top watering moves water and salts down and out of the drainage hole. Bottom watering draws water up and leaves salts at the soil surface.Where fertilizer salts end upTop wateringBottom wateringSalts flush outthe drainage holeSalts collectat the surface
Water moving down carries salts out; water moving up leaves them on top.

How Long Should You Bottom Water Plants?

Most pots need 10 to 30 minutes; take the pot out as soon as the surface feels damp. Small 4-inch pots in fast-draining mix can be ready in under 10 minutes, while a 10-inch pot of dense, dry mix can take 30 or more. Leaving a pot in water for hours keeps the bottom of the root ball saturated, which is the same as standing in a full saucer.

How to Flush Salts If You Bottom Water

Rinse the mix from the top every few weeks if bottom watering is your routine. The University of Maryland Extension recommends leaching houseplants every four to six months by pouring at least twice the volume of the pot through the soil. It also advises leaching every new plant the first time you water it.

White mineral salt crust on the surface of houseplant potting soil
  1. Take the plant to a sink or tub.
  2. Pour plain water over the soil in a slow stream, at least twice the volume of the pot.
  3. Let it drain before returning it to its saucer.
  4. Flush before you fertilize, not after, so you do not rinse the new fertilizer away.

A white crust on the soil or on the rim of a clay pot is the sign that it is time to flush. Spider plants, dracaenas and calatheas show salt damage first, as brown leaf tips.

Which Method Should You Use?

African violet being bottom watered in a saucer with dry leaves
Bottom watering vs top watering: how to choose for each plantA decision flow: top water by default; bottom water plants with sensitive leaves or hard, dried soil; and flush bottom-watered pots from the top every few weeks.Which method for which plantDefault: top waterUntil it drains, then empty the saucerFuzzy leaves or crown rot riskBottom water, as for African violetsSoil dried hard, water runs throughSoak from below for 20 to 30 minutesBottom watering as a routineTop water every few weeks to flush salts
Top water by default and bottom water only where it solves a problem.

Use this checklist to choose for each plant.

ChooseIf
Top wateringIt is a routine watering for most foliage plants and succulents
Top wateringYou see white crust or brown tips from salt buildup
Bottom wateringThe plant has fuzzy or crown-sensitive leaves, such as African violets
Bottom wateringThe soil has dried hard and water runs straight through
BothYou bottom water most of the time and top water to flush salts

Whichever method you use, check the soil before you water. Most problems blamed on the method come from watering too often, which you can rule out with the overwatered vs underwatered checklist.

Common Bottom and Top Watering Mistakes

  • Bottom watering for months without flushing. Salts build up in the top inch and burn the roots, which shows as brown tips and a white crust.
  • Soaking for hours. A pot left in a tray overnight stays saturated at the base, and root rot can start within a week or two.
  • Sharing one tray for many pots. Water moving between pots carries fungus gnat larvae, root rot organisms and pests from one plant to the next.
  • Top watering a dried-out root ball. Water runs down the gap at the pot edge and out the hole, so the plant stays dry even though the saucer fills.
  • Using cold water on African violets. Cold water on the foliage causes pale rings that do not fade.

Is bottom watering better than top watering?

Not as a routine. Colorado State University Extension says top watering is better because bottom watering can build up soluble salts in the soil.

How long should you bottom water plants?

About 10 to 30 minutes, until the soil surface feels damp. Take the pot out then and let it drain.

Can you bottom water all plants?

Most plants in pots with drainage holes tolerate it, but they still need a top watering every few weeks to flush salts.

Which plants should be bottom watered?

African violets and other plants that spot or rot when their leaves or crown get wet, plus any plant whose soil has dried too hard to absorb water.

Does bottom watering prevent fungus gnats?

It can help, because the surface stays drier, but a soggy pot from a long soak still breeds gnats in the lower soil.

How often should I flush my plants with water?

Every four to six months, per the University of Maryland Extension, using at least twice the pot volume of water.

Key Takeaways

  • Top watering is the better default because water draining out carries salts with it.
  • Bottom watering pulls salts upward, so top water every few weeks to flush them.
  • Bottom water for 10 to 30 minutes, until the surface feels damp, then drain.
  • African violets get pale ring spots from cold water on their leaves, so water them from below.
  • Flush every pot with twice its volume of water every four to six months.
  • Empty saucers 10 to 15 minutes after any watering.

Top water as your routine and keep bottom watering for violets, dry soil and seedlings. For the plants that need it most, see the African violet watering guide and the indoor plant watering guide.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *